ACCA FR Notes: A2d Advantages and disadvantages of historical cost accounting

Independent of asset depreciation from physical wear and tear over long periods of use, an impairment may occur to certain assets, including intangibles such as goodwill. With asset impairment, an asset’s fair market value has dropped below what is originally listed on the balance sheet. An asset impairment charge is a typical restructuring cost as companies reevaluate the value of certain assets and make business changes.

  1. The revenue would be recognized at the historical invoiced sales price rather than an estimate of future cash flows or the current market value.
  2. However, historical cost accounting concept also has shortcomings or disadvantages.
  3. Using consistent historical costs is a prudent approach that underpins accuracy and accountability in financial reporting.

Julius owns an investment firm that has acquired various properties across southern America. Assuming that inflation levels across the region have doubled over the recent years, the property investments are not worth anything close to what Julius spent on acquisition. In order to determine the actual position, it is necessary to know how individual product prices have changed over the period. The same problem arises in relation to the trend in profits, but in this case the position is further complicated by difficulties in measuring the profit figure itself.

Disadvantages of Historical Cost Accounting

The subtraction of accumulated depreciation from the historical cost results in a lower net asset value, ensuring no overstatement of an asset’s true value. A historical cost is a measure of value used in accounting in which the value advantages of historical cost accounting of an asset on the balance sheet is recorded at its original cost when acquired by the company. The historical cost method is used for fixed assets in the United States under generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP).

Historical Cost: Definition, Principle, and How It Works

It is the amount paid to initially purchase or acquire an asset, recorded on the balance sheet. Historical cost is the cash or cash equivalent value of an asset at the time of acquisition. Imagine if someone were to have purchased an acre of land 10 years ago for $10,000 and that land is now worth $20,000.

The principle requires that only realised revenues be included in the income statement. In the balance sheet, the realisation principle requires adherence to the historical cost of the assets until the asset is sold, despite any changes in the value of the assets (resources) held by a business enterprise. However, historical cost accounting concept also has shortcomings or disadvantages. Firstly, historical cost accounting concept is fixed, which means it is recorded based on the original cost in the invoice or receipt. This historical cost approach provides a verifiable objective basis for valuing assets and liabilities. It also reflects the principle of accounting conservatism, where expenses and liabilities are recognized as soon as possible, while revenues and assets are only recorded when there is objective evidence to support them.

All such information is provided solely for convenience purposes only and all users thereof should be guided accordingly. Historical Cost Accounting does not disclose the effect of closing stock on profit. Therefore, profit due to the overvaluation of inventories is mixed up with business profits, and does not show the correct profitability. Historical cost accounting does not disclose the effect of closing stock on profit. Yarilet Perez is an experienced multimedia journalist and fact-checker with a Master of Science in Journalism.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Historical Cost Accounting

In 2007 the price was Rs. 5 each, but the supplier announces that on January 1, 2008 the price will be increased to Rs. 6. During 2007 the items were sold at Rs.6 each and the company had other expenses of Rs. 10,000. In periods of inflation, therefore, inflated profits result in substantial fall in the operating capital and in turn, in the operating capability of a business enterprise.

It records asset costs objectively while recognizing losses in value over time through depreciation and write-downs. Under the historical cost principle, most assets are to be recorded on the balance sheet at their historical cost even if they have significantly increased in value over time. For example, marketable securities are recorded at their fair market value on the balance sheet, and impaired intangible assets are written down from historical cost to their fair market value. The historical cost principle states that a company or business must account for and record all assets at the original cost or purchase price on their balance sheet. No adjustments are made to reflect fluctuations in the market or changes resulting from inflationary fluctuations.

After five years, the firm will have generated Rs. 1,50,000 and distributed Rs. 50,000, leaving a balance of Rs. 1,00,000 representing the original capital, which may be returned to the owners, or reinvested. However, if there have been significant increase in prices in the meantime, the firm will find that it has insufficient funds to replace the equipment, which has now reached the end of its economic life. On January 1, 2007, a firm buys a machine for Rs. 1,00,000 which it expects to last for five years and have no scrap value. It has no other assets or liabilities and distributes all of its profits to its shareholders. Its profits before providing for depreciation is expected to be Rs. 30,000 per year. A company buys 20,000 items each year on January 1 and sells them all by the end of the year.

Historical cost is a fundamental basis in accounting, as it is often used in the reporting for fixed assets. It is also used to determine the basis of potential gains and losses on the disposal of fixed assets. Since historical accounting is based on realisation principles, profit can easily be manipulated. By accelerating or retarding the timing of the realisation of gains, profits can be increased or decreased. Management’s ability to control what profits are reported is known as ‘income smoothing’.

This has led to the corporate sector to depend largely on external funds rather than on retained earnings. Consequently, the cost of borrowings, i.e., the rate of expected return has increased as well as higher debt equity ratios in the corporate sector. Similarly, equity costs tend to increase as debt cost increase because equity shareholders also require a higher return in view of the increased risks and the decreased purchasing power caused by inflation. Thus, despite making a profit it is not in a position to maintain its operating capability without borrowing or raising further capital. The longer the delay between goods being acquired and their being sold, the more serious the situation is likely to be.

When an asset is written off due to asset impairment, the loss directly reduces a company’s profits. Therefore during inflation, additional funds are needed to finance operations (e.g., inventories, plant and equipment, working capital, other assets) in order to support a given physical volume of production and sales. The level of these additional funds (investment) is likely to increase as a result of rising prices, but this will not be measured by the amount of distributable profits reported by historical cost accounts. In general, whenever there is a time lag between acquisition and utilisation, historical cost may well differ significantly from current cost. Accordingly, HCA tends to report ‘inflated’ or “inventory’ profits and lower costs of consuming stocks and fixed assets during a period of increasing prices.

Recording accounts receivable at net realizable value provides a more conservative and realistic view of this asset’s value. The accounts receivable balance is later adjusted to reflect its net realizable value – the amount the company reasonably expects to collect based on past payment history. A financial professional will offer guidance based on the information provided and offer a no-obligation call to better understand your situation. In this case, the company’s higher sales figures are attributable to inflation and not to an increase in sales. Inflation causes many other problems and dislocations, such as the following, which are not considered in HCA.

Leave a Reply